This past summer at a game convention up in Hartford I met the voice of God – Jeff Steizer, the whole “Voice of God” thing being a title for his role, the iconic multiplayer announcer. After waiting in line for a couple of minutes, I shook his hand, spoke briefly with him, and took a photo (along with getting a signed copy of Halo 4). Later in the convention, I attended his panel, where he discussed his time with Microsoft and the three studios that have had involvement with Halo: Bungie, 343 Industries, and technically Halo Studios, which is really just 343 in disguise. He specifically talked about how 343 Industries / Halo Studios attempted to replace him as a voice actor when they first took over, something I found very offensive and had previously not known. A couple of months after that, Halo Studios had their workers laid off by Microsoft en-masse and primary control of Halo was handed over to Activision. It’s been a few months since then. I’ve had time to collect my thoughts about this whole kerfuffle, and I have come up with a three step plan that will put Halo back on track. I can safely say that I’ve become a Halo doctor after my intense studying of the past few months, and though Activision would never listen to some random high schooler about Halo, I figured I’d let those of you in this high school who also care about Halo hear what I think the solution is.

Step One: Fix the Writing

Okay, so there’s a lot of issues with Halo’s lore. Don’t even get me started on the whole “Humans are forerunner” thing, but if we use this as an example to dig at exactly why we got here, it’s actually pretty useful. Bungie-era Halo said that humans are forerunners – they built the rings, that’s why Guilty Spark says to Master Chief that humans are forerunners, and that’s why Master Chief is a “reclaimer” – because he’s a human coming back to what his ancestors built. Now, ask 343 Industries, and they’ll tell you that it’s because the Forerunners, after their little conflict with the ancient humans, decided that after they all went extinct because of the Halo rings, the humans could inherit their toys and take the mantle of responsibility. According to them, Master Chief is a literal “reclaimer”, because he’s, y’know, reclaiming stuff. It’s a little hard to follow, right? That’s because both studios had very different perspectives on where Halo’s story should go. Bungie era Halo is a space epic about humans facing unbelievable odds against a genocidal, overly zealous group of space aliens, and 343 era Halo is so the easiest solution is a reboot, right? Blow it all up, who cares? However, that’s where a critical error with Halo begins; Halo is a very, deeply, religious game. Now, I’m no priest, but there are so many times where Halo adapts its story from biblical tales (all life in the universe being saved from a parasite called the “Flood” on a “Ark” is pretty on the nose if you ask me) and part of what made Halo’s writing so interesting was its use of biblical callbacks and likewise, criticism of religious fervor and extremism. By rebooting Halo, you lose the Bungie-era story that made Halo so interesting while cutting off the 343 issues that would plague modern Halo. Imagine, for a second, nuking your house because you’ve got a mouse problem. It’s a similar situation, and so the best solution is to call the exterminator: Reboot from Halo 3 onward, erasing all (yes, all) 343 era lore. Focus heavily on the wonder that made Halo so effective, and likewise, focus on continuing to tell a story that keeps the original Bungie critiques that made Halo’s story so effective.

Step Two: Fix the Gameplay

Unlike Halo’s story, I’ll admit that 343 made important advancements in Halo’s gameplay. Sure, REQ packs and loadouts? Certainly not the smartest choice. However, it was so clear that 343 did actually learn their lesson, and in my opinion, Infinite has clearly the best gameplay of any Halo game. It’s modern, with sprint and clamber that are necessary if you want to draw new players to the game (something that Halo must do to stay alive in the modern gaming world, more on that later!), but likewise didn’t turn Halo into a movement shooter (something it is not). For those of you who dread Halo’s newer gameplay, we’re at a point where Halo players could simply adjust settings within the game to replicate that no-sprint classic feel. Campaign Evolved is direct evidence: want no sprint? You turn on a skull. Simple as that. In multiplayer, just create classical Halo playlists where these settings are enabled, and now you’ve satisfied the half of the fanbase that wishes to cling on to the past. Furthermore, if the modding scene is anything to go by, adapt these favorites into new modes: big-scale warfare with new vehicles and UNSC v Covenant gamemodes are easy pickups that can keep players hooked in the long run. Maintain a course on the core arena gameplay that makes Halo famous, but likewise don’t be afraid to try new modes and new gameplay styles. Just preserve that same Halo feel.

Step Three: Steer the Course

This one is broad, but it covers multiple topics. First, keep the modding scene blooming: this should be obvious, but don’t pull a Nintendo and DMCA every project that appears. If the Digsite mods were anything to go by, allow the modders to do what they do best and keep Halo afloat during times where there are no games or news for long periods of time. It’s free work, after all. These next two “asks”, however, are probably my least likely and most ambitious: the community needs to fix itself and the leadership needs to be perfect. The Halo community probably hates Halo more than anybody else, and though criticism is fair, the 343 era has turned many Halo fans into raving critics that want to do nothing more than criticize any new Halo content and worship Bungie (which, surprise surprise, did make mistakes too). Of course, it’s unlikely that this will ever change, but the community has to be more receptive of new content, and be willing to give it a try before spitting it out because papa Bungie didn’t make it. Likewise, the leadership has to allow core Halo visionaries to fulfill their visions. The game, if people like Joe Staten are allowed to have their say, will be good. There’s no need for Microsoft bigwigs to come down and make changes, as time and time has proved, it simply doesn’t work. It’s also been proven by multiple former developers that 343’s culture was highly toxic because of the leadership, and it’s reflected in the product that was output, so keep the culture upbeat. On top of that, communicate as much as possible with the community, as it allows Halo to continue to be relevant beyond simple release dates and temporary hype. Conventions like HaloFest are a perfect opportunity for times of communication, and if they hone in on communication, Halo can prosper. Finally, this is incredibly hopeful, but please, for the love of everything beautiful, avoid microtransactions. Nobody likes them. Don’t do it.

Will Halo be fixed? Probably not. It’s incredibly wishful to think Halo can just turn the course after running through an iceberg for about 10 years straight. However, I’d be no better than many Halo community members if I gave up on Activision instantly, so perhaps we will see Halo turn around and finally be on top of the world like it once was. The takeaway lesson? Keep the OG Bungie spirit alive and don’t make Halo your own pet project. Follow these words, and Halo has a chance, but don’t, and you follow the steps of 343 Industries to being laid off.

Drawing by Aiden Cronk

Leave a Reply

Trending